Biblical Grounds for Divorce: My View

by Roger Barrier

In order to lend some credibility to my comments, you may need to know that I’ve counseled married, remarried, cohabitating and divorced couples and individuals for over forty years. Nothing surprises me anymore. Of the hundreds of letters that I receive to Ask Roger, almost one-half of them deal with marriage issues.


While the issues in marriage, and in cohabitating, remain much the same, I’m not the same. When I first began pastoring (at age 20) the rules for divorce were clear. First, adultery was always grounds for divorce (Matthew 5:31-21). Second, a Christian married to an unbeliever may get a divorce if the unbeliever wants to get out of the marriage (1 Corinthians 7:12-16).


In those days it was easy for me to apply the rules. People either obeyed them or they didn’t. If they didn’t they weren’t really welcome in our fellowship.


I look back with sadness. A lot of people in broken marriages turned to the church for help and comfort and all we had to offer were two rules.


The more contact I’ve had with those divorced and divorcing, and with people who needed to get out of miserable, dangerous, abusive and broken marriages the more my heart aches. Too many situations simply don’t fit the rules.


Let me give you an example of a letter that I recently received from a woman with two daughters. She is tragically trapped in a marriage sham but feels is obligated to keep married because God will punish her if she divorces the miserable dead beat.


Dear Roger,

I am 23 years old,and i got married when i was 19. i been married 5 years now. i got 2 kids… as of right now my husband is pass out .he was drunk and he came home and pick a fight and when i told him i just want to sleep he punch me and grab my hair ans says i don’t care about him just because i didn’t want to talk to him…i really don’t know what to do.. i love my two daughter so much..i don’t want them to be grow up and see that they don’t have their parent toghter..Please Pray for me and my daughters…today is sunday i suppose to go to the church, but i can’t my eyes can’t open cause i been crying all night..Please help me pray for me and my daughter….


Today, I try to interpret the Bible’s teachings on divorce–and there are many–as a selection of godly principles. With this approach, I find the Scriptures full of help which provides much truth to work with in helping hurting people.


No two marriages are alike. Each needs individual attention. Any decision to divorce — or to recommend it — comes only after a careful consideration of a multitude of factors. Prayer and seeking God’s will in every situation is essential.


1. Adultery is always grounds for divorce (Matthew 5:31-32).


2. A Christian may divorce a non-Christian if the non-Christian wants to divorce (1 Corinthians 7:12-16).


3. Physical abuse, and in many cases emotional, cruel and/or mental abuse may mean that it is time to consider abandoning the marriage (Malachi 2:16).


“God hates divorce; but, He also hates a man covering himself with violence” (Malachi 2:16). The term in Malachi 2:16, comes from a Hebrew word that can also mean, “covering his wife with violence.”


I advise any woman who has been hit by her husband to consider getting as far away from him as soon as possible — and never to look back–divorce or otherwise. Continued belittling and mental and emotional badgering fits under the “violence” umbrella. Notice that this principle holds true if the roles are reversed and the wife is the one instigating the violence.


By the way, can you imagine that a quick way to break your marriage vows is to hit the one that you promised to love.


4. The husband who consistently refuses to live up his responsibility of loving his wife as Jesus loved the church, may, in some cases, have violated his marriage vows and made the marriage contract null and void (Ephesians 5:25-33).


Paul taught that the marriage vows made by a husband include loving and sacrificing for his wife as Jesus loved and sacrificed His life for His church. According to the vows laid out in the Bible, the husband is to invest his life in loving his wife and caring for her needs even before he takes care of his own. He is responsible to make her into the best woman she can possibly be. He is to watch over her and protect her from “evil things”. He is responsible for his wife’s spiritual development so that one day she may be pure and holy as she comes into the presence of Christ.


Based on years of observation, many husbands walked out on their wives long ago—even while they both lived under the same roof.


5. The wife who undermines and/or disrespects her loving husband, may, in some cases, have violated her marriage vows and made the marriage contract null and void (Ephesians 5:22-24).


As you read the Ephesians five passage, notice that while the husband is commanded to love his wife, his wife is never asked to love him. She is to obey and respect him; but she’s never told to love him. Many have trouble with a wife being told to obey and respect her husband. It doesn’t seem right or fair.


Let me tell you what I see going on here. Women whose husbands are fulfilling their roles of loving and sacrificing their lives for them don’t have to be told to love their husbands. Loving men like that comes naturally. It is easy to love and respect some one who has your best interests at heart.


6. The husband who refuses to get a job in order to meet the needs of his family is worse than an unbelieving non-Christian (1 Timothy 5:8). He has forfeited his role as a husband and violated his marriage vows.


Of course, there are times when few/no jobs are available. This is different from the husband who refuses to work. In this case, the wedding vows are not broken by the failure to make a living.


7. God never intended for people who are divorced without Biblical grounds to remain single forever (Genesis 2:18 and Matthew 5:32; 19:8-9).


Jesus said that it is a wrong to marry someone who has been divorced who did not have the proper grounds for divorce. In the same way, it is not right for a person who is divorced without biblical grounds to remarry.


However, the overriding principle here comes from before the Fall when God says to Adam, “It is not good for man to be alone” (Genesis 2:18). It is my opinion that after an appropriate amount of time, and after seasons of brokenness, humility, confession and repentance, God is still intends for marriage to be the first defense against loneliness.


8. If you have proper grounds for a divorce, then you have proper grounds to remarry (1 Corinthians 7:15, 39).


9. If your previous partner has remarried, reconciliation is impossible. There is freedom to remarry.


10. In certain cases it is God’s will to remain unmarried (1 Corinthians 7:10-11).


11. When a marriage is irrevocably marred and broken it may well be time for both parties to consider simply picking up the pieces and starting over again (John 8:1-12).


Remember how Jesus gave a second chance to the woman caught in adultery (John 8:1-12). He helped her to pick up the pieces of her broken life and start over again.


Jesus is still in the business of helping people pick up the pieces of their broken lives so that their best days are ahead!


So, Let’s Practice.


I have repeated below some of the marriage and cohabitation questions I have recently received at Ask Roger. Take a few moments, just for fun, and think about how you might handle each one. Some are easy. Others are inscrutably difficult.


“What if I am married to a person with an incurable personality disorder that I never should have married in the first place, whose aberrant behavior is destroying our family? Is it OK for me to get a divorce?”


“What if I can handle my spouse’s angry and belittling verbal abuse—but I see my children being mentally and emotionally destroyed before my very eyes?”


“What if my husband puts a gun in my mouth and threatens to shoot me?”


“What if I don’t love my spouse anymore?”


I’ve heard Christians say, “Well, I don’t love him anymore.” Not loving someone has never been grounds for divorce. The Bible says that we are to love our wives/husbands. If you can’t do that, then love her/him as your neighbor. If you can’t love her/him as a neighbor, then, love your enemy.


“What if my spouse is involved in illegal/criminal behavior (gambling, drugs, gun running, etc) which could get us all in trouble?”


 “My husband divorced me for another and I’m really praying that God will break them up and bring him back to me.”


“One month after i got married to the father of my two youngest children i found out he was having an affair.… He moved another women into his home….after about six months of rejection i filed for divorce. Our divorce will be final in man’s eyes. my question is in references to Matthew 19: 3-11 can i re-marry? will i commit adultery? will any future marriage be cursed? did i do the right thing?


“When I became a Christian I learned that I had no biblical grounds for my divorce. In order to make things right should I divorce my new wife in order to return to the old one?”


“In our culture polygamy is both allowed and encouraged. The missionary told me that the Bible says that we are to have only one wife and family. I have three wives and nineteen children. Is he right? If I choose one, the others will be put on the street to starve with no support. What should I do?”


“I have been taught in my church that it is okay to leave someone abusing you, etc. And being separated-But it is not okay to get divorced and marry someone else (unless widowed).”


“If God doesn’t recognize divorce, and marriage is a covenant, how can someone get remarried?”


“I’m told if your first spouse is alive, you are committing adultery if you remarry.”


“Is it OK to have sex with my ex?”


“My boyfriend likes looking at porn more than he likes having sex with me. What should I do?”


“I married my then spouse for all the wrong reasons. I thought things would change after the marriage, but they got worse. My then spouse confessed he didn’t believe in god and he brought all types of evils into our family. After many failed attempts to get him to join a church or get counseling I decided it only be wise to leave him. My concern is on remarrying, we were married in a court building, not on biblical grounds. So am I able to remarry if I cleanse myself, repent for those sins?”


When I talk to high school and college kids on the subject of marriage I ask them to raise their hands if they intend to get married some day. Most all hands go up. Then I ask how many have actually seen the type of marriage they would like to have? A few hands raise. Not many.


Then, I encourage them to look at everyone else in the group; one of every two persons in the room will be divorced at least once. I have never yet married anyone who intended to be in the divorced group—but half of all people tragically end up there any way.


A failed marriage is an awful thing. The ripples of pain flow outward in ever widening circles just as a stone tossed into the middle of a quiet pond sends ripples out in all directions.


So, make having a successful marriage a top priority in your life. You want to be in your rocking chair, rocking on the front porch some day in retirement with your very best friend—the love of your life. That will be sweet.



You may also like

Update Required Flash plugin